IT'S A RELIEF to have a book arguing against a recently leftist tendency to make identity a sacrosanct category that is written by neither a cultural conservative nor a white man. Both left(ish) white men (e.g., Mark Lilla) and cultural conservatives (take your pick) who get anxious about "woke" immediately invite a hermeneutic of suspicion, since they seem to be protecting their own privilege.
As an established author and director of the Einstein Forum, Neiman does enjoy a degree of privilege, but as a Jewish woman, she would also know about not being "seen," so her argument seems far from self-interested.
This short book challenges the prioritizing of identity by making a case for the Enlightenment--Rousseau, Voltaire, Diderot, Kant, and all of the 17th- and 18th-century thinkers who made cases that universal values do exist, that impartial justice can be arrived at, that social progress is possible.
Neiman acknowledges that the Enlightenment's conceptions of universality, impartiality, and progress have a lot to answer for, as they often provided camouflage for imperial adventures and racial and gender oppression. The imposition of one group's values on other groups towards the end of greater exploitation often occurred under the false flag of universal values, impartial justice, la mission civilisatrice, etc. That the conceptions were misused and abused, however, does not mean (she maintains) that they were wrong. If we understand them rightly, they can still be helpful. We very much need them, in fact.
Right-leaning thinkers--Nietzsche, Heidegger, Schmitt--have been beating up on the Enlightenment for generations. More damaging, Neiman thinks, has been the left-wing critique by Foucault, which has left the impression that any well-intentioned attempt at institutional reform will quickly be co-opted into an even more oppressive crackdown.
Neiman's answer to that attitude is to distinguish hope from optimism.
"As Kant extended the argument, we cannot act morally without hope. To be clear: hope is not optimism. Optimism (and pessimism) makes predictions about a distant future and an inaccessible past. Hope makes no forecasts at all. Optimism is a refusal to face facts. Hope aims to change them. When the world is really is peril, optimism is obscene. Yet one thing is predictable with absolute certainty: if we succumb to the seduction of pessimism, the world as we know it is lost."
Put me in mind of Demogorgon's famous final lines in Shelley's Prometheus Unbound.
I have a feeling this book is important. I hope I am not the only one picking it up.

No comments:
Post a Comment