Loads of Learned Lumber

Thursday, December 11, 2025

Terence Winch and David Lehman, eds., _Best American Poetry 2025_

 IT SEEMS SO strange that this is the last one, but if what I read on the internet is true, it is. 

I can understand David Lehman being ready to be done with it, but wouldn't someone else (Kevin Young?) be willing to take it on? I'm using it sells at least reasonably well, since every year it shows up in  bookstores that do not carry much other poetry. I mean...what gives?

I did not recognize Terence Winch's name when I saw it on the cover, which was a little surprising--the  guest editors tend to be a relatively famous poets. It turned out, though, that I must have seen his name at least a few times, since he has had poems in BAP several times and has been very involved in the BAP Blog. 

His selections tend to the mainstream, I suppose we could say--mainly in conversational language, mainly about readily recognizable experiences and observations, mainly the sort of thing that turns up abundantly in the reviews (Kenyon/Southern/Georgia/Massachusetts/Threepenny et alia),  mainly by people with established careers.

It would have been nice to go out with a bang, I think, stir in a few things from Zyzzva or Oversound or Conjunctions, but, well, no. It's an enjoyable read, but more of a plunk than a bang.

At least Heather Christle is in it.


No comments: